EditorialIndustry
Gamesdle Saturday Scorecard: GTA VI Drew 38% of Our Readers, and Reddit Was Split
Palash Bagchi
· 13 min read

This is the first Gamesdle Saturday Scorecard. Every Saturday we look back at the seven days of stories on Gamesdle News and answer four questions: which games drew the most readers, how people felt about them, what the publishers are doing to keep players engaged, and what gamers liked and disliked. We show our work, so every chart below comes with a plain account of how it was made and what it does and does not prove.
This week covers 34 stories published between November 14 and November 21, 2026: 27 news stories and 7 editorials. Together they drew 12,443 page views. The mood data comes from 513 Reddit comments across 89 threads in 57 subreddits where we shared those stories.
How to read this scorecard
Four definitions carry the whole report.
Readers means page views on a story page, counted since the story went live. A view is not a unique person, and a story published on Friday has had far less time to collect views than one published last Saturday. Treat the rankings as a strong signal, not a precise measurement.
Emotion is the feeling expressed in a Reddit comment. Gamesdle has no accounts or comments of its own, so we read the comments on the Reddit threads where our stories were shared. An AI model labels each comment with one of 14 emotions (excitement, joy, amusement, admiration, nostalgia, hope, curiosity, neutral, confusion, scepticism, disappointment, frustration, anger, sadness), says what the feeling is about, and flags sarcasm. These are the moods of Reddit commenters, who skew vocal, not of everyone who read us.
Weight gives popular opinions more say. A comment counts as 1 plus the natural log of 1 plus its upvotes, so a comment with 128 upvotes counts about 5.9 times as much as one with none. An upvote is a reader saying "me too", and the log keeps one viral comment from drowning out everyone else.
Mood score runs from -1 (every weighted comment negative) to +1 (every one positive). It is the weighted share of positive emotions (excitement, joy, amusement, admiration, nostalgia, hope) minus the weighted share of negative ones (scepticism, disappointment, frustration, anger, sadness). Neutral, curious and confused comments sit in the middle. Faded bars and hollow bubbles in the charts rest on fewer than 12 labelled comments, so read them as hints.
One caution about amusement: it counts as positive, but a joke at a game's expense is also amusement. That makes the scores slightly warmer than a survey would be.
1. Which games drew the most readers
Chart data
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| GTA series | 4,771 · 38.3% |
| Steam Machine | 1,538 · 12.4% |
| Call of Duty | 1,450 · 11.7% |
| Warcraft | 1,080 · 8.7% |
| Zelda: Ocarina remake | 640 · 5.1% |
| Fallout | 529 · 4.3% |
| Roblox | 428 · 3.4% |
| Marvel / Doom | 373 · 3.0% |
| Tomb Raider | 373 · 3.0% |
| League of Legends | 354 · 2.8% |
| Netflix 3 Body Problem | 212 · 1.7% |
| Star Wars: Galactic Racer | 181 · 1.5% |
Embed this chart
Paste this on any page. It links back here and follows your reader's light or dark setting.
What we measured. We added up the page views of every story about the same game, so GTA's number combines 11 stories (the GTA VI launch coverage plus our GTA V and GTA IV editorials), while Steam Machine's is a single story.
What it shows. GTA took 4,771 of the week's 12,443 views, or 38.3%. Steam Machine (1,538) and Call of Duty (1,450) came next, and those three topics together drew 62% of all traffic. Warcraft, the Zelda: Ocarina of Time remake and Fallout followed, each under 9%.
What it means. GTA's dominance is a launch-week effect: the game came out inside this window and everyone wanted something about it. The more interesting number is the average per story. GTA's 11 stories averaged 434 views each, while Steam Machine and Call of Duty each pulled more than three times that from a single story. One sharp, specific story about a game people already care about beat a pile of general coverage. We should publish fewer GTA stories and make each one answer a question readers are asking.
2. The stories behind the traffic
Chart data
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| GTA 6 drops hirable sex w… | 2,436 |
| Valve warns Steam Machine… | 1,538 |
| Treyarch lays off Zombies… | 1,450 |
| World of Warcraft: Foreve… | 852 |
| Some GTA VI boxed copies… | 559 |
| GTA 6 reviews land a 99 M… | 552 |
| Roblox will convert games… | 428 |
| Kevin Feige says Marvel's… | 373 |
Embed this chart
Paste this on any page. It links back here and follows your reader's light or dark setting.
What we measured. Page views for each individual story, top eight.
What it shows. The top story, GTA 6 drops hirable sex workers, drew 2,436 views, nearly a fifth of the week on its own. Next came Valve's warning that Steam Machine prices may rise (1,538) and Treyarch's layoff of Zombies writer Craig Houston (1,450). The 99 Metascore story, the kind of news you might expect to win, drew 552, about a quarter of the top story.
What it means. Readers came for things that change what they can do, pay or play: a removed feature, a price warning, a layoff of someone whose work they know. Scores and trailers drew far less. Controversy is not the only lever, though. The boxed-copy code story (559) was practical rather than angry, and it did well because it affected a purchase decision.
Our editorials averaged 199 views against 409 for news, so news stories pulled about twice as much. Editorials earn their place on tone and warmth, as the Fallout result below shows, not on raw reach.
3. What kind of news readers came for
Chart data
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| Console | 4,173 |
| Industry | 3,053 |
| Releases | 1,739 |
| Pc | 1,736 |
| Hardware | 1,610 |
| Daily games | 106 |
| Indie | 26 |
Embed this chart
Paste this on any page. It links back here and follows your reader's light or dark setting.
What we measured. Page views grouped by each story's category.
What it shows. Console led with 4,173 views, driven by GTA. Industry came second (3,053), thanks to the Treyarch layoff plus a run of GTA business stories. Releases, PC and hardware each landed between 1,600 and 1,740. Our own daily-games category drew 106 views and indie drew 26, together about 1% of the week.
What it means. Gamesdle is a daily-games site, but its news audience arrives for big-title news. That is not a problem by itself, since it brings readers in, but we are not yet turning them into players. Section 11 covers what we plan to do about it.
4. The week's emotional mix
Chart data
| Item | Share |
|---|---|
| Neutral | 23.8% |
| Amused | 18.2% |
| Frustrated | 15.6% |
| Sceptical | 12.9% |
| Let down | 10.3% |
| Warm | 9.1% |
| Angry / sad | 6.2% |
| Curious | 3.8% |
Embed this chart
Paste this on any page. It links back here and follows your reader's light or dark setting.
What we measured. Every labelled Reddit comment, grouped into eight emotion families and weighted by upvotes. "Warm" bundles excitement, joy, admiration, nostalgia and hope. "Curious" bundles curiosity and confusion. "Angry / sad" bundles anger and sadness.
What it shows. The largest block was neutral (24%), which means comments that ask questions or pass on facts. Among actual feelings, amusement led (18%), followed by frustration (16%), scepticism (13%) and disappointment (10%). Warm feelings were only 9%. Net mood was -0.18, and 14% of the weighted comments were sarcastic.
What it means. Reddit is a place where people go to argue and joke, and it showed. Positive and negative are not symmetrical: amusement is a big share of the positive side, and much of it was gallows humour about news that bothered people. Treat -0.18 as "fairly sceptical crowd", not "a bad week".
5. How Reddit felt about each game
Chart data
| Item | Mood (-1 to +1) | Comments |
|---|---|---|
| Fallout | +0.45 | 26 |
| Zelda: Ocarina remake | +0.18 | 8 |
| Steam Machine | +0.08 | 70 |
| GTA series | −0.11 | 239 |
| Warcraft | −0.11 | 31 |
| Marvel / Doom | −0.52 | 60 |
| Tomb Raider | −0.54 | 56 |
| League of Legends | −0.56 | 5 |
| Roblox | −0.75 | 3 |
| Call of Duty | −0.76 | 11 |
Embed this chart
Paste this on any page. It links back here and follows your reader's light or dark setting.
What we measured. The mood score for every game with at least three labelled comments. Bars to the right are warmer, bars to the left are colder, and faded bars have fewer than 12 comments behind them.
What it shows. Fallout was the warmest game with enough comments (+0.45 across 26). Steam Machine was mildly positive (+0.08, 70 comments). GTA (-0.11, 239 comments) and Warcraft (-0.11, 31) sat just below zero. The two clearly cold games with a solid sample were Tomb Raider (-0.54, 56) and Marvel (-0.52, 60). Call of Duty (-0.76) and Roblox (-0.75) were colder still, but only 11 and 3 comments stand behind them.
What it means. The warmth tracks the kind of news. Fallout was a nostalgic editorial plus a remaster roadmap. Tomb Raider and Marvel were stories where fans felt a publisher was changing something they loved or telling them something they did not believe. We will keep the 12-comment rule so one noisy thread cannot make a game look loved or hated.
6. Which feelings each game stirred up
Chart data
| Story | Amused | Warm | Neutral | Curious | Sceptical | Let down | Frustrated | Angry / sad |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| GTA series | 25% | 7% | 24% | 3% | 11% | 8% | 18% | 5% |
| Steam Machine | 12% | 20% | 31% | 12% | 6% | 4% | 9% | 5% |
| Warcraft | 13% | 12% | 33% | 7% | 12% | 2% | 14% | 7% |
| Fallout | 38% | 27% | 15% | 0% | 10% | 3% | 3% | 4% |
| Marvel / Doom | 7% | 0% | 34% | 0% | 38% | 8% | 7% | 5% |
| Tomb Raider | 10% | 7% | 8% | 3% | 9% | 31% | 26% | 7% |
Embed this chart
Paste this on any page. It links back here and follows your reader's light or dark setting.
What we measured. For each game with at least 12 labelled comments, the percentage of its weighted comments in each emotion family. Darker cells mean a bigger share.
How to read it. Go row by row and look at where the colour piles up.
- GTA was split four ways: amused (25%), neutral (24%), frustrated (18%) and sceptical (11%). That is what a divided crowd looks like. The removed hirable-sex-worker mechanic produced jokes and nostalgia on one side and "that is not what GTA is" frustration on the other.
- Steam Machine was calm. Neutral (31%) and warm (20%) lead, plus a visible curious column (12%) of people comparing storage options.
- Warcraft was mostly neutral (33%), with frustration, amusement and scepticism each around 12 to 14%. Much of it was players explaining how an experience-points rule works.
- Fallout was the amused and warm game: about 38% amused and 27% warm, with little anger.
- Marvel was sceptical (38%) and neutral (34%): few people were furious, many simply did not buy the explanation.
- Tomb Raider was a disappointment game. "Let down" (31%) and frustrated (26%) together are more than half of the weighted comments.
What it means. Two games can share the same overall score and feel completely different. GTA and Warcraft both sit at -0.11, but GTA is a loud argument and Warcraft is a quiet shrug. The heatmap is how we tell which one we are looking at.
7. Attention against mood
Chart data
| Item | X | Mood | Comments |
|---|---|---|---|
| GTA series | 4,771 | −0.11 | 239 |
| Steam Machine | 1,538 | +0.08 | 70 |
| Call of Duty | 1,450 | −0.76 | 11 |
| Warcraft | 1,080 | −0.11 | 31 |
| Zelda: Ocarina remake | 640 | +0.18 | 8 |
| Fallout | 529 | +0.45 | 26 |
| Marvel / Doom | 373 | −0.52 | 60 |
| Tomb Raider | 373 | −0.54 | 56 |
| League of Legends | 354 | −0.56 | 5 |
Embed this chart
Paste this on any page. It links back here and follows your reader's light or dark setting.
What we measured. Each bubble is a game. The horizontal position is page views on a log scale, the height is the mood score, and the size is the number of labelled comments. Hollow bubbles rest on fewer than 12 comments.
What it shows. Fallout is the only solid bubble in the warm half. Steam Machine and Warcraft cluster near zero in the middle. GTA is the biggest bubble by far, slightly below the line. Tomb Raider and Marvel overlap in the cold zone at about 370 views each. Call of Duty is the notable hollow bubble: a big audience, a very cold mood, and almost nobody commenting.
What it means. The danger zone for a publisher is bottom right: lots of readers, unhappy ones. Nothing was fully there this week, but Call of Duty is the closest. A story about a layoff pulled 1,450 views from people who clearly care, yet the Reddit conversation was short and sad. That is an audience worth serving, and the one we know least about.
8. What gamers liked and disliked
This section reads the actual comments behind the scores, paraphrased. These are the most upvoted themes per game.
GTA VI
- Liked: the series' sandbox humour and nostalgia (people recalled the removed mechanic fondly as a gag), a slow, story-first opening (a few called it a plus), and awards recognition for the narrative.
- Disliked: the removal itself, which some saw as moving away from what GTA is and others called inconsistent next to the violence. Also reports of frame-rate dips, theft from boxed copies, the anti-"woke" review bombing (disliked by other fans), and the Game Awards omission of Jason's actor.
Steam Machine
- Liked: how easy it is to upgrade (people added their own SSD or an external drive), and how fast the cheaper waitlist cleared. The top tip was to switch from the 2 TB queue to the 512 GB model and add storage yourself.
- Disliked: rising component prices and the uncertainty about future cost.
Tomb Raider: Legacy of Atlantis
- Liked: not much, in the comments we read. The loudest voices wanted the classic game back.
- Disliked: crafting, a skill tree, timed buffs and a scanner in a remake of the 1996 original. The most upvoted comments called this checklist design.
Fallout
- Liked: the Vault 101 exit as the best visual storytelling in the series, and the memories of a first game in the wasteland.
- Disliked: that the news was not new. Several commenters said they had known about the remasters for months.
Marvel and Doctor Doom
- Liked: Doom as the villain for Secret Wars.
- Disliked: the claim that the pivot predated the Kang actor's firing. Many readers thought the timeline did not add up.
Call of Duty (Treyarch)
- Liked: Zombies lore, remembered with nostalgia.
- Disliked: the layoff, and its timing next to a trailer celebrating the series' campaigns. Some also felt the Zombies story had become too complicated.
Warcraft, Zelda, Roblox, League of Legends
- Warcraft players liked Arthas as a tragic hero and disliked unclear experience rules. The Zelda remake drew playful comments about not dying (only 8 labelled, so treat as a hint). Roblox developers doubted the promise that submitted code will not train AI. League of Legends readers were split on the new look.
9. What each game is doing to keep players engaged
This is how our coverage describes each publisher's approach, not what they have told us privately.
- GTA VI: a story-led open world with Jason and Lucia as AI partners, awards and critic momentum, economy tuning that is expected to continue after launch, local partnerships such as the Vice City deal in Miami, and a staggered regional launch.
- Steam Machine: scarcity and tiering. Waitlists, two models, a push to move buyers to the cheaper one, and a promised update in January.
- Zelda: Ocarina of Time remake: companion-app data as shareable content. The Zelda Notes app reported that 18% of players had died to ReDeads, a statistic that spread, and a family-friendly E10+ rating.
- Fallout: franchise stacking, with Fallout 3 and New Vegas remasters, Fallout 5 in pre-production and a Fallout 76 expansion in 2027, as covered here.
- Warcraft: fast, iterative economy tuning, such as the dungeon experience hotfix aimed at boosting.
- Tomb Raider: a developer-video drip leading to a February 12, 2027 launch, mixing a 1996 remake with newer systems. That mix is exactly what fans pushed back on.
- League of Legends: a full refresh (New Dawn) with a new client, map visuals and per-champion builds, with the old Classic mode ending in January.
- Roblox: supply-side acquisition. Free conversion of games from other engines, with developers keeping their IP.
- Star Wars: Galactic Racer: post-launch retention through four-player split-screen in early 2027, fixing an online-only gap.
- Call of Duty: no engagement move this week. The story was a layoff.
What it means. The strategies that earned goodwill were the ones that gave players something concrete: a way to cut the wait, a shareable statistic, a faster fix. The ones that earned friction changed the nature of a beloved thing without asking.
10. What commenters said about us
Chart data
| Item | Share |
|---|---|
| The game or news itself | 60.0% |
| Replies and off-topic | 32.5% |
| Our article | 6.0% |
| Gamesdle | 1.6% |
Embed this chart
Paste this on any page. It links back here and follows your reader's light or dark setting.
What we measured. Where each labelled comment pointed its feeling: at the game or news itself, at our article, at Gamesdle, or elsewhere, such as replies to other commenters.
What it shows. 60% of the weighted comments were about the game or news, 33% were replies and off-topic remarks, 6% were about our articles and 1.6% were about Gamesdle itself. By count, 40 of 513 comments (about 8%) were aimed at us.
What it means. The small slice matters. About nine comments said the news was old, along the lines of "we have known this for months". Several others questioned whether the post was written by AI or a bot, and one commenter complained about how often we post. One commenter noted a story was out of date after a same-day hotfix. These are fair points. When a story rewrites another outlet's report, it carries that outlet's timing and we are slower than Reddit. We will respond with dates, not defences:
- Put the original report's date near the top of every story.
- Add a short "what changed since" line to anything older than a day.
- Share fewer links per day and add something of our own, such as the editorials you are reading.
11. The Gamer's Choice poll, and our daily games
The Game of the Year poll under each story collected 21 votes this week: 7 for Zelda: Ocarina of Time, 7 for GTA VI, 6 for Resident Evil Requiem and 1 for Phantom Blade Zero. Out of 12,443 views, that is 0.17%. Thirteen of the 21 votes came from just two stories, the sex-worker story and the Steam Machine story, so the poll converts on pages with a large audience and little elsewhere. We will move a one-line prompt above the story and see whether that changes it. Treat the vote counts as a pulse, not a ranking.
On daily games, our Krillion Space review drew 106 views, one of the smallest audiences of the week. The path from a hit-title reader to a daily-game player is the gap this scorecard exists to track, so next week we will link each big-title story to a matching game you can play today.
What to watch next Saturday
- Whether GTA's share of readers holds once launch week is over.
- Whether Valve's January pricing update changes the Steam Machine conversation.
- Whether Tomb Raider's pushback grows as its February 12 launch gets closer.
- Whether our freshness changes move the share of comments aimed at us.
Method and limits
- Window: stories published November 14 to 21, 2026. Views are cumulative page counts as of the evening of November 21 and had not stopped growing.
- Games group several stories. Groupings are our choice and are listed in each chart's data table.
- Moods come from 513 Reddit comments labelled by an AI model, so they carry labelling error, and 14% of the weighted comments were flagged as sarcastic, which is hard to read for any labeller.
- One thread, on the sex-worker story, supplied about a quarter of all comments, so GTA's mood leans on a single crowd.
- Stories we shared late or not at all have no mood score. Games with fewer than 12 comments are shown faded or hollow.
- Every chart has a "Chart data" table and an embed code under it, so you can check our numbers or use the chart on your own site with a link back.
Key takeaways
- GTA coverage drew 4,771 of the week's 12,443 views (38.3%); one story about the dropped hirable-sex-worker mechanic got 2,436 on its own.
- Stories that change what players can do or pay out-read scores and trailers: the Steam Machine price warning (1,538) and the Treyarch layoff (1,450) beat the 99 Metascore story (552).
- Reddit's mood on our stories was net negative (-0.18). Fallout was warmest (+0.45); Tomb Raider (-0.54) and Marvel (-0.52) were coldest among games with 50+ comments.
- Tomb Raider fans rejected crafting and skill trees in the remake; Steam Machine buyers praised upgradability and worried about component prices.
- About 8% of comments were aimed at our articles or Gamesdle, mostly about old news and AI suspicion, so every story will now carry the source's date.
- Our daily-games coverage drew about 1% of views, and the Game of the Year poll turned 0.17% of views into votes.
How readers reacted
Disappointed
- Neutral 88%
- Disappointed 12%
- Reads
- 111
- Reddit threads
- 6
- Upvotes
- 5
- Upvoted
- 82%
- Comments read
- 5
From 5 Reddit comments on this story, each weighted by its upvotes. · November 22, 2026
#saturday scorecard#weekly analysis#gta vi#steam machine#reddit sentiment#gamer reactions#games industry
Gamer's Choice
Game of the Year
·
A Gamesdle reader poll. Not affiliated with The Game Awards, or with any publisher or studio.
Featured

Written by
Founder and editor, Gamesdle
Palash Bagchi founded Gamesdle, the daily games board, and edits Gamesdle News. He picks which stories run, checks every story against the original report and claims, before it goes live, and links the source, wherever applicable, on each one.
CoversDaily gamesWord gamesGames industryIndie games




