GTA 6 reviews land a 99 Metascore, tying Ocarina of Time at the top
Palash Bagchi
· 5 min read

Grand Theft Auto 6 now holds the top spot on Metacritic with a Metascore of 99, Polygon reports in a review roundup published November 18, the same day Rockstar Games releases it on PlayStation 5 and Xbox Series X.
That 99 equals the score of The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time, Nintendo's 1998 game. Polygon says GTA 6 has displaced it in Metacritic's all-time ranking, and presumes the new game holds a slim edge in figures the site does not show.
The scores
The roundup lists these numbers:
- Grand Theft Auto 6 on Metacritic: 99
- Grand Theft Auto 6 on OpenCritic: 98
- Grand Theft Auto 5 on Metacritic: 97
- Red Dead Redemption 2 on Metacritic: 97
That puts GTA 6 above both of Rockstar's previous major releases. The outlet describes an almost unbroken run of five-star and 10/10 verdicts.
What critics praised
Scale, ambition and artistry drew the most praise, per the report. IGN's Luke Reilly gave the game a 10/10 and called it "one of the most impressive games ever made."
Reilly, like many others, saw a blend of two Rockstar traditions: the grown-up tone of Red Dead Redemption 2 and the anarchy of earlier GTA entries.
Kotaku's Zack Zwiezen pointed to physical detail. He described suds from a pressure washer pooling on concrete, and a tram station holding more than 100 distinct NPCs, each moving on its own. "It's a massive experience that is filled with more content and more ideas than some entire game franchises," he wrote.
Jason, Lucia and a softer GTA
The Guardian's Keza MacDonald found the game hard to categorize and said she often got tangled in its controls and systems. Her review, like many, centered on the romance between the two leads, Jason and Lucia.
MacDonald called Lucia's characterization a major shift for a series she described as once misogynistic. She also noted that the game rewards small kindnesses, such as texting a partner a selfie, helping a neighbor or putting trash in a bin.
"Jason and Lucia are not extravagant caricatures, but two people trying to make it in a world totally stacked against them," she wrote.
The dissent
ScreenHub's Alice Clarke came closest to a negative take, according to Polygon. She gave four stars out of five and said the game did not match the hype at first.
Clarke, along with some other critics, flagged a sluggish start. "I spent the first dozen hours of the game completely bored," she wrote, calling the early stretch an on-the-rails "Good Boyfriend Simulator" with little room for mischief.
Polygon's counterpoint
Polygon's Giovanni Colantonio read that same opening, in which Jason waits for Lucia to get out of jail, as the core of the game's emotional and political weight. "Justice is big business in the Florida-inspired state of Leonida," he wrote.
He called the story uneven and padded with repetitive chases, but argued its heart makes up for that. In his view, the relationship gives players a reason to push through Leonida's daily grind.
GTA 6’s empathy is bound to be the most controversial thing about it.
Why the 99 is a tie with an asterisk
The visible record is a tie, and the claim of first place rests on an assumption the outlet itself flags. Both games display 99. Polygon's case that GTA 6 sits higher depends on a decimal gap it calls presumable, not confirmed.
That matters for how the headline claim travels. Any outlet repeating "best game ever" is leaning on Metacritic's ordering, not on a higher public number. The firmer measure in the roundup is the comparison with Rockstar's own catalog: 99 against 97 for both GTA 5 and Red Dead Redemption 2.
The OpenCritic score of 98 points the same way. Two aggregators landing within a point of each other suggests the acclaim is broad rather than driven by a handful of outliers.
The opening hours are the real split
The critics disagree less about quality than about what a GTA game is supposed to feel like. Clarke and Colantonio describe the same early section. One found it boring and restrictive; the other found it essential.
That gap is useful for players. Anyone buying on the promise of instant chaos may hit the same wall Clarke did, because several reviewers agree the start is slow. Those who value story are being told by Polygon's own critic that the patience pays off.
Even the harshest review cited is four out of five. The dissent is about pacing and expectations, not about whether the game works.
Empathy as the new center of gravity
The reviews describe a series that has moved its emotional core from mayhem toward a relationship. The evidence comes from several directions: rewards for small acts of kindness, a lead couple framed as ordinary people, and a political reading of Leonida's justice system.
Colantonio predicts the game's empathy, not its violence, will spark the most argument. That is his forecast, not an established outcome. Still, if it holds, the long-running debate about GTA and lawlessness would shift to new ground.
For Rockstar, the reception reads as validation of carrying lessons from Red Dead Redemption 2 into its biggest series. Reviewers repeatedly tied the two together.
What the roundup leaves open
The scores settle the critical verdict, but not several practical questions. The report names only PlayStation 5 and Xbox Series X as launch platforms, with no word on other versions.
It also gives no detail on performance by platform or price. MacDonald's note about getting tangled in controls hints at a learning curve, but the roundup does not say how widespread that complaint was.
The launch is staggered by time zone, and Polygon notes players in New Zealand already have access. Early player impressions will test whether the opening's slow burn lands as Colantonio describes or as Clarke does.
The number at the top of Metacritic is the headline, but the argument critics are actually having is whether a GTA built on tenderness is still the GTA people came for.
Key takeaways
- GTA 6 has a Metascore of 99, matching Ocarina of Time
- GTA 6 scores 98 on OpenCritic
- GTA 5 and Red Dead Redemption 2 both hold 97 on Metacritic
- Launches November 18 on PlayStation 5 and Xbox Series X
How readers reacted
Joyful
- Neutral 62%
- Joyful 19%
- Sceptical 19%
- Reads
- 394
- Reddit threads
- 5
- Upvotes
- 7
- Upvoted
- 100%
- Comments read
- 5
From 5 Reddit comments on this story, each weighted by its upvotes. · November 18, 2026
#gta 6#rockstar games#metacritic#playstation 5#xbox series x#open world
Source
Based on reporting by Polygon, published November 18, 2026. Gamesdle News rewrote and edited it. Read the original report →
Gamer's Choice
Game of the Year
·
A Gamesdle reader poll. Not affiliated with The Game Awards, or with any publisher or studio.
Featured
Industry
GTA 6's AI partner got final passes before launch, Rockstar says
Rockstar spent GTA 6's final months refining Jason and Lucia as AI partners, and kept tuning core systems its production head calls scary to touch late.
Kotaku · 4 h ago · 4 min read
Editorial · Industry
Miami's $3.9 million Vice City deal needs a receipt, not a morals fight
Palash Bagchi · 15 h ago · 2 min read
Editorial · Daily Games
Tired of Krillion? Krillion Space is the change of scenery
Palash Bagchi · 6 d ago · 2 min read

Written by
Founder and editor, Gamesdle
Palash Bagchi founded Gamesdle, the daily games board, and edits Gamesdle News. He picks which stories run, checks every story against the original report and claims, before it goes live, and links the source, wherever applicable, on each one.
CoversDaily gamesWord gamesGames industryIndie games






