Skip to the board
Gamesdle lionGamesdle

PC

Binding of Isaac Repentance+ review-bombed over AI music in GTA mode

Palash Bagchi
· 4 min read

Readers' emotion: Frustrated
Promotional image for The Binding of Isaac: Repentance+
Image: Kotaku

The Binding of Isaac: Repentance+ is being review-bombed on Steam after players found AI-generated music in a Grand Theft Auto 6-themed Daily Run, Kotaku reports. Creator Edmund McMillen says he did not know the tracks were in the game.

The expansion's Steam page now sits at 9 percent positive user reviews. An emergency update has pulled the music, but publisher and co-developer Nicalis has not accepted responsibility or explained how the tracks got there, according to the outlet.

The Vice City daily run

Repentance+ began as a free update on PC in 2024. It reached PS5, Xbox Series X/S and Switch 2 this week, timed to launch on the same day as Rockstar's Grand Theft Auto 6.

Steam players got a free update alongside the console release. Patch notes on Valve's store teased a crime-themed surprise hidden in that day's Daily Run.

Typing the seed "V1CE BSMT" before a run loaded a GTA-inspired version of the roguelike with special weapons and its own soundtrack. That soundtrack is what players identified as AI-generated.

Player anger and the Steam rating

Complaints spread quickly on the game's subreddit. One player called the Easter egg something nobody had asked for and accused the team of using AI on it anyway. Another argued that corner-cutting has become normal across the industry.

Much of the frustration landed on Nicalis. The report notes that complaints about bugs, latency and quality control appear to have been building for some time before this week.

One recent Steam review asked McMillen to reclaim the game. The same reviewer complained that an update players had waited more than a year for brought only a handful of bug fixes.

McMillen's response

McMillen posted on X that he woke up to the backlash, had not known about the generated music, and was investigating how it happened while working to get it removed.

obviously I had no idea it featured generated music in the daily run

— Edmund McMillen, creator of The Binding of Isaac

Valve's storefront asks developers to disclose content built with AI-generated assets on the store page. Repentance+ carried no such disclosure, Kotaku notes, despite the publicity push around the update.

McMillen had also recently told Eurogamer that the GTA 6 launch-day timing was Nicalis' idea. He described the plan as "a fun experiment."

Analysis: The disclosure gap is the real exposure

The missing AI disclosure turns an unpopular creative choice into a store-policy problem. Steam asks for disclosure of AI-generated assets, and Repentance+ shipped AI music without one.

The emergency update removes the tracks, which fixes the content players objected to. It does not explain how material requiring a disclosure reached a storefront that asks for one. The report does not say whether Valve has responded, so any consequence there stays an open question.

The timing matters too. The music arrived in a featured, heavily promoted mode rather than a forgotten corner of the game, which made discovery close to certain and the lack of a label more conspicuous.

Why the spotlight falls on Nicalis

McMillen's public denial leaves Nicalis as the party expected to explain. The creator says he had no idea about the music, and he has separately credited Nicalis with the launch-day stunt.

Those two statements do not prove who made or sourced the tracks, and the report does not establish that. But with the creator stepping back and the publisher silent, the most direct reading is that only Nicalis can close the gap. Until it does, players are left to fill it themselves, and the subreddit and review comments show they already blame the publisher.

The review that asked McMillen to retake control points at a split in how players see the project: the creator as trusted, the publisher as the problem. A silence from Nicalis does nothing to soften that view.

A review-bomb with older roots

The 9 percent rating reflects more than one bad Daily Run. Kotaku describes complaints about bugs, latency and quality control as building before this week, and at least one review pairs the AI issue with frustration over thin bug fixes.

That makes recovery harder. Removing the music answers the trigger, not the backlog of grievances underneath it. Reviews driven by long-running quality concerns are unlikely to flip simply because a soundtrack was swapped out.

A rating that low is also visible to anyone browsing the store. For a 2024 PC update now relaunching on three consoles, the Steam score becomes part of its first impression elsewhere.

What the GTA 6 stunt traded away

Sharing a launch day with GTA 6 bought attention but also put every flaw under brighter light. Kotaku says the stunt may have worked as marketing, and the hedge there matters.

A themed mode built around Rockstar's release invited more eyes than a routine Daily Run would. More eyes meant faster discovery of the AI tracks. McMillen's own Eurogamer description of the idea as a lighthearted experiment sits awkwardly next to the scale of the reaction.

Console players meeting Repentance+ for the first time this week arrive in the middle of that reaction. Their experience depends on whether the emergency patch and any further fixes land cleanly across platforms.

What is still unanswered

Several basic facts remain unsettled, and each would shape how this story ends. The open points include:

  • Who created or commissioned the AI-generated tracks
  • Whether Nicalis will publicly explain or take responsibility
  • Whether Valve will treat the missing disclosure as a policy issue
  • Whether the emergency update fully cleared the music from every version

An account from Nicalis would answer most of these at once. Continued silence would leave McMillen's post as the only explanation on record, and a quick removal cannot substitute for knowing how AI music slipped into a promoted mode without anyone, including the game's creator, flagging it first.

Key takeaways

  • Repentance+ reached PS5, Xbox Series X/S and Switch 2 this week, alongside GTA 6
  • Seed "V1CE BSMT" unlocked a GTA-inspired Daily Run with AI-generated music
  • The expansion's Steam user rating fell to 9 percent positive
  • An emergency update removed the AI music; Nicalis has not explained it

How readers reacted

Frustrated

  • Frustrated 65%
  • Sceptical 23%
  • Amused 12%
Reads
77
Reddit threads
2
Upvotes
0
Upvoted
9%
Comments read
5

From 5 Reddit comments on this story, each weighted by its upvotes. · November 22, 2026

#the binding of isaac#repentance+#nicalis#edmund mcmillen#steam#generative ai

Source

Based on reporting by Kotaku, published November 22, 2026. Gamesdle News rewrote and edited it. Read the original report →

Gamer's Choice

Game of the Year

2026

Pick your game of the year to see how other readers voted.

A Gamesdle reader poll. Not affiliated with The Game Awards, or with any publisher or studio.

Palash Bagchi

Written by

Founder and editor, Gamesdle

Palash Bagchi founded Gamesdle, the daily games board, and edits Gamesdle News. He picks which stories run, checks every story against the original report and claims, before it goes live, and links the source, wherever applicable, on each one.

CoversDaily gamesWord gamesGames industryIndie games

WebsiteXLinkedInAll 44 stories →

How Gamesdle News works: sources, AI help, corrections

More news